A brush with death

Twelve young adults died when a wooden porch in Lincoln Park collapsed early Sunday morning; 57 people were injured. A high school classmate, Kelly McKinnell, was one of those who died:

Kelly McKinnell, 26, used her eyes and a gift for photography to affect those around her. Lynne Wellen, coordinator of the adult education program at the Latin School of Chicago, said McKinnell graduated from the Latin School in 1995.

She came back in 2001 to teach digital photography in the adult education program and was applying to schools to get a graduate degree in photography.

“She was a wonderful young woman. She really was. And she was a terrific teacher,” Wellen said. “Very full of life, very upbeat. An exceedingly positive young woman.”

McKinnell’s mother, Jean Ware of Barrington, said her daughter had just mailed her application to the Brooks Institute of Photography in Santa Barbara, Calif., on Saturday morning.

“She’s an only child … she’s my only child,” Ware said. “You just get numb.”

Kelly and I weren’t close, but everyone at the Latin School, which we graduated in the same year, was a lot closer than average because each graduating class had only 75 to 80 students.

She was a nice girl, and even back in high school — when she shot for the yearbook — an evidently talented photographer.

There’s a bigger spook to this for me because only last Monday I attended a friend’s birthday party, a barbecue held on a wooden porch. These are designed as walkways, not as places for scores of people to congregate. To be honest, it never occurred to me that it might not be safe, though there were perhaps only a dozen people at that party.

This is yuppie Chicago’s version of E2.

Grab bag

(1) This New Republic piece on “the selling of the Iraq war,” where truth about the reliability of the intelligence on WMD was ” the first casualty, is an excellent overview of how it went down and what it means. What’s interesting about it is that it’s an attempt by TNR to salvage the value of pre-emptive war from people like Dubya. TNR was for the war for the reasons Dubya stated.

Unlike most conservatives, they’re not looking to play a shell game and argue that the liberation of Iraq was the point all along. Still, that misses the point. It’s the policy, not the people. Now that we have started giving the OK on pre-emptive war, it will be much easier for presidents to take us into future wars. Sometimes those wars will be based upon sound intelligence, but at this point the odds of that don’t seem very strong.

(2) Sen. Richard Lugar says U.S. forces will be in Iraq for at least five years, at least. Is it possible, is it wise, to leave sooner? Cato’s Charles Pena says yes, and points to Afghanistan and Panama as examples of successful quick exits. I’m not so sure.

It’s not clear to me that U.S. security is worse off by our presence in Iraq. Agreeing to leave immediately as so many in Iraq clearly want may result in a resurgence of Hussein and friends or some other dastardly coalition that will be at least oppressive and maybe virulently anti-American and supportive of terrorism. On the other hand, I’d hate to have to face the mothers and fathers of the one to two U.S. troops killed every day since “major hostilities” ceased.

(3) A couple of good columns from Steve Chapman: Title IX, and the Internet law no one missed.